Advertisement

Can I give the qurbani money to charity instead?

Clothing donation box in Durham
Photo: Ildar Sagdejev ( Specious ), CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

No, giving the money as ordinary charity does not replace qurbani. All four Sunni schools see qurbani as a specific act of worship: sacrificing an animal for Allah in the days of Eid al-Adha. Giving cash is good, but it's a different deed. The good news is that you can pay a charity to do the qurbani for you, and the meat still goes to people in need.

Why the animal itself matters

Qurbani is not only about feeding people. It's a ritual linked to the story of Ibrahim and his son, done at a fixed time, with a specific animal, in Allah's name. The Prophet ﷺ sacrificed every year and encouraged those who could afford it to do the same; he even said that someone with the means who doesn't sacrifice should not come near the Eid prayer place (Sunan Ibn Majah 3123). Scholars say this shows the act of sacrifice is what's asked for, not just its price.

The Quran explains what really reaches Allah:

لَن يَنَالَ ٱللَّهَ لُحُومُهَا وَلَا دِمَآؤُهَا وَلَـٰكِن يَنَالُهُ ٱلتَّقْوَىٰ مِنكُمْ "Their meat will not reach Allah, nor will their blood, but what reaches Him is piety from you." Quran 22:37

What the schools say

  • Hanafi: qurbani is wajib (required) for an adult Muslim who has the nisab amount during Eid. If the days pass and someone failed to do it, they should give the value of a sheep in charity as a make-up. That's a late repair, not a free choice.
  • Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali: qurbani is a strongly recommended sunnah. Doing it is better than giving its price as sadaqah, because it follows the Prophet's ﷺ practice.

So under every view, if you can afford it, sacrifice the animal. See What is qurbani and do I have to do it?

Qurbani is already charity

The meat is meant to be eaten and shared, and much of it goes to the poor. In one year of hardship the Prophet ﷺ even told people not to store their qurbani meat beyond three days, so it would reach those who needed it (Sahih al-Bukhari 5569). If your heart is with people in crisis, the easiest answer is to book your qurbani through a trusted charity working in a poor country. See Can I pay for qurbani abroad instead of locally?

What if I can't afford it?

If you don't have the means, qurbani isn't asked of you, and giving whatever you can as sadaqah is still rewarded. Also keep in mind that zakat, sadaqah and qurbani are three separate things; one doesn't cover another. See What is the difference between zakat and sadaqah?

Key points
  • Cash charity does not replace qurbani for someone who can afford it.
  • Hanafis allow giving the value only as a make-up after Eid has passed.
  • Paying a charity to sacrifice for you still counts as qurbani.
  • If you can't afford it, you're excused; give what you can.
Tip: Want to do both? Book one qurbani share through a charity and add a small extra donation for the same project. Your sunnah is done and your extra sadaqah goes further.

People also ask

Can I celebrate Eid while grieving a loved one?

Yes, you can celebrate Eid while grieving and still be sad. The three-day mourning rule, widows, and gentle ways to get through Eid day.

Read the full answer →
Can men and women mix at Eid parties?

It depends: men and women can share an Eid gathering with Islamic manners, like modesty and no seclusion. Where views differ and tips for hosts.

Read the full answer →
How do I explain Eid to my non-Muslim friends?

Explain Eid to non-Muslim friends simply: it's the Muslim festival, held twice a year with prayer, family, food and gifts. Easy comparisons and tips.

Read the full answer →
What gifts do Muslims give on Eid?

Muslims usually give Eidi money to children, plus clothes, sweets, perfume and Islamic items to family and friends. Ideas and what to avoid.

Read the full answer →
Can I celebrate Eid at a restaurant?

Yes, you can celebrate Eid at a restaurant. Choosing halal food, avoiding alcohol at the table, prayer times, and bringing non-Muslim family.

Read the full answer →