Advertisement

Is it wrong to feel relief when a difficult relative dies?

Mitake Town Library 2019-12 ac
Photo: Asturio Cantabrio, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

No, feeling relief when a difficult relative dies is not wrong or sinful. Feelings that come on their own are not held against you. What matters in Islam is how you act: avoid celebrating or insulting the dead, and let yourself process the mixed emotions honestly.

Why relief is so common

If a parent, sibling or relative was abusive, controlling, addicted or constantly hurtful, their death can bring a sudden sense of safety. You might also feel relief that a long illness is over, or that years of caregiving have ended. Relief often sits next to sadness, guilt, anger or numbness. All of this is a normal human response, and many people feel it without ever saying it out loud.

Allah judges actions, not passing feelings

You are not accountable for an emotion you didn't choose:

لَا يُكَلِّفُ ٱللَّهُ نَفْسًا إِلَّا وُسْعَهَا "Allah does not charge a soul except [with that within] its capacity." Quran 2:286

Interestingly, the Prophet ﷺ once described a death as bringing relief. When a funeral passed, he said the person was either "relieved or relieved of": a believer is relieved from the hardships of this world, while people, land, trees and animals are relieved of a wrongdoer (Sahih al-Bukhari 6512). So the idea that a death can bring relief to others is not foreign to Islam.

What to avoid

  • Don't speak ill of the dead in public. The Prophet ﷺ said, "Do not abuse the dead, for they have reached what they sent forward" (Sahih al-Bukhari 1393). Talking privately with a therapist or trusted friend about what really happened is different, because it is for your healing.
  • Don't celebrate. Showing joy at a funeral hurts other mourners and goes against Muslim manners.
  • Don't judge their fate. Their final reckoning is with Allah alone.

Grieving a complicated relationship

Sometimes you grieve the relationship you never had more than the person themselves. That is real grief too. Tears and sadness are a mercy, as the Prophet ﷺ said when his son died: "The eyes shed tears and the heart grieves" (Sahih al-Bukhari 1303). See How do I deal with grief as a Muslim?

If the relative hurt you, you don't have to force forgiveness right away. See Do I have to forgive someone who abused me as a Muslim? And if other family members are still difficult, healthy limits remain allowed. See How do I set boundaries with toxic family as a Muslim?

Key points
  • Relief after a hard relationship ends is natural, not sinful.
  • Allah holds you to account for actions, not passing feelings.
  • Avoid insulting the dead in public or celebrating the death.
  • Complicated grief is real; talking it through helps.
Tip: Try writing an unsent letter to the person, saying everything you never could. Many people find it lets the relief, anger and sadness settle, so the guilt loosens its grip.

People also ask

How do I deal with emotional abuse in my marriage?

Dealing with emotional abuse in marriage: Islam forbids harm between spouses. Signs, safety steps, counseling, and when khul' or divorce is allowed.

Read the full answer →
Is emotional eating a sin in Islam?

No, emotional eating is not a sin in itself in Islam. Islam teaches moderation, so aim for gentle balance and better ways to cope, not guilt.

Read the full answer →
Should I tell my future spouse about my mental illness?

Yes, you should usually tell your future spouse about a significant mental illness before the nikah. Islam values honesty in the marriage contract.

Read the full answer →
How do I deal with resentment as a Muslim?

Dealing with resentment as a Muslim starts with admitting the hurt, then letting go of the grudge. Islam honors those who forgive, even from afar.

Read the full answer →
How do I support a family member with schizophrenia?

Support a family member with schizophrenia with patience, treatment and practical care. Islam rewards caring for family, within your limits.

Read the full answer →