Advertisement

Is stealing from the government haram?

USSR 1933-03-16 Registered Foreign Exchange Tax Cover reverse
Photo: Soviet postal authorities, Public domain via Wikimedia Commons

Yes, stealing from the government is haram. Public money belongs to everyone, so taking it dishonestly wrongs millions of people at once. That includes benefit fraud, tax evasion, fiddling expenses and taking public property, whether the government is Muslim or not.

Public money is a trust

Some people think the state is "nobody's money", so taking from it doesn't count. Islam sees it the other way round: public funds belong to the whole community, including the poor, the sick and children. The Quran uses the word ghulul for secretly taking from shared or public wealth:

وَمَن يَغْلُلْ يَأْتِ بِمَا غَلَّ يَوْمَ ٱلْقِيَـٰمَةِ "...And whoever betrays [by taking unlawfully] will come with what he took on the Day of Resurrection..." Quran 3:161

Even a needle counts

The Prophet ﷺ said that if anyone appointed to a public post hides from us even a needle or anything bigger, it is ghulul, and he will bring it on the Day of Resurrection (Sahih Muslim 1833). When one of his tax collectors came back saying, "This is for you, and this was given to me as a gift," the Prophet ﷺ stood up and criticized him, asking whether he would have received those gifts if he had stayed at home with his parents (Sahih al-Bukhari 7174). Using a public role for personal gain is a form of theft.

Everyday examples

"But it's a non-Muslim government"

Scholars are clear that the wealth of non-Muslims living in peace with you is protected, just as yours is. When you live in a country under its laws and enjoy its services, you have an agreement with it, and betraying that agreement is not allowed.

If you've done this before, repent sincerely and pay back what you took where you can, for example by declaring an overpayment and agreeing a repayment plan. Allah accepts those who turn back to Him.

Key points
  • Taking public money dishonestly is theft from everyone.
  • Ghulul, even a needle's worth, will be carried on the Day of Judgement.
  • This applies to non-Muslim governments too.
  • Repent and repay whatever you can.
Tip: If you've been overpaid by a government agency, report it yourself. Self-reporting usually leads to a simple repayment plan and a clear conscience.

People also ask

Is trespassing haram?

Yes, trespassing is haram when you enter private property without permission. Public footpaths and legal right-to-roam land are fine to walk on.

Read the full answer →
Does Islam believe in innocent until proven guilty?

Yes, Islam treats people as innocent until proven guilty: the accuser must bring evidence, reports must be verified and doubt protects the accused.

Read the full answer →
Can Muslims sign a petition to change a law?

Yes, Muslims can sign a petition to change a law. Peacefully asking for a fairer law is enjoining good and sincere advice, which Islam encourages.

Read the full answer →
Is it haram to ignore a parking ticket?

Yes, ignoring a valid parking ticket is generally haram, since parking rules are an agreement and debts must be paid. Unfair tickets can be appealed.

Read the full answer →
What should Muslims do with lost property they find?

Muslims should return lost property they find by announcing it or handing it to police or lost-and-found; Islam treats it as a trust (amanah).

Read the full answer →