Advertisement

What does Islam say about secularism?

British Columbia Parliament Building in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
Photo: Michal Klajban, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

It depends on what "secularism" means. Islam does not split faith off from personal life, so secularism as a belief that religion should have no role in life clashes with it. But a secular state that stays neutral and protects freedom of religion is somewhere Muslims can live, practise and contribute with a clear conscience.

Two kinds of secularism

The word gets used in two very different ways, and the Islamic answer is different for each:

  • Secularism as a worldview: the idea that God and religion are irrelevant to how people should live, and that faith is just private sentiment. Islam disagrees with this. For a Muslim, prayer, honesty, money, family and work all belong to worship.
  • Secularism as a political arrangement: the state doesn't adopt an official religion and treats all citizens equally regardless of belief. This is how most of Europe and the USA work, and it's what lets mosques open, hijabis work and converts change religion freely.

Islam is a whole way of life

The Quran speaks about worship, but also about contracts, inheritance, justice, trade and how to treat neighbours. So a Muslim doesn't switch off their faith at the office door. That's not about forcing anything on others. The Quran itself says faith can't be forced:

لَآ إِكْرَاهَ فِى ٱلدِّينِ "There shall be no compulsion in [acceptance of] the religion." Quran 2:256

Living by Islam yourself and respecting other people's choices go together. See Is there freedom of religion in Islam?

Living as a Muslim in a secular country

Most scholars living in the West agree that Muslims can be loyal, law-abiding citizens of a secular state. You keep your agreements, pay your taxes and follow the law, unless a law forces you to commit a sin, which is rare in practice. The early Muslims who fled to Abyssinia lived safely under a just Christian king, and the Prophet ﷺ praised that land for its justice. See Do I have to follow the laws of my country as a Muslim?

What scholars debate

Scholars differ on what the ideal Islamic state looks like and how sharia relates to modern constitutions. Some see secular democracy as a practical, acceptable framework where Muslims can still promote good; others hold that a Muslim-majority state should be guided by Islamic law. Almost all agree that Muslims in non-Muslim countries should work within the system peacefully. See Is democracy compatible with Islam?

Key points
  • Secularism as "religion doesn't matter" clashes with Islam.
  • A neutral state that protects religious freedom is workable for Muslims.
  • Faith can't be forced (Quran 2:256), on anyone.
  • Scholars differ on the ideal state, but agree on peaceful citizenship.
Tip: When someone asks if you "believe in secularism", ask which kind they mean. Saying "I value a state that protects everyone's freedom of belief, and my faith guides my own life" is honest and usually opens a good conversation.

People also ask

Is it haram to bribe an official?

Yes, bribing an official is haram, and so is taking a bribe. The Prophet cursed both. See what counts as a bribe and the narrow exception.

Read the full answer →
Can Muslims testify as a witness in court?

Yes, Muslims can testify as a witness in court and often should. The Quran forbids hiding testimony and calls for truth even against yourself.

Read the full answer →
Can Muslims be conscientious objectors?

Yes, Muslims can be conscientious objectors and refuse to fight in a war they believe is unjust. What Islam says and how to object legally.

Read the full answer →
Can Muslims hold dual citizenship?

Yes, Muslims can hold dual citizenship. Islam has no rule against two passports; what matters is keeping both commitments. Legal checks to make.

Read the full answer →
Is it a sin to break traffic laws?

Yes, deliberately breaking traffic laws is a sin for Muslims: road rules protect lives and you agreed to keep them. Honest mistakes are forgiven.

Read the full answer →