Advertisement

What does Islam say about torture?

Prison Corridor - HDR
Photo: Nicolas Raymond from Bethesda, Maryland, USA, CC BY 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Islam forbids torture. Every human being has God-given dignity, and the Prophet ﷺ warned that Allah will punish those who torment people in this world. Classical scholars also held that a confession taken by force has no legal value.

Human dignity comes from Allah

The Quran states that dignity belongs to every human being, not only to Muslims or to the innocent:

وَلَقَدْ كَرَّمْنَا بَنِىٓ ءَادَمَ "And We have certainly honored the children of Adam..." Quran 17:70

Because that honor is given by Allah, no ruler, soldier or interrogator has the right to strip it away. Even a criminal remains a person with rights. See Is sharia law compatible with human rights?

The Prophet's ﷺ clear warning

A Companion, Hisham ibn Hakim, once passed some people in Syria who had been made to stand in the sun as a punishment over unpaid taxes. He went to the governor and quoted the Prophet ﷺ: "Allah will torment those who torment people in this world." The governor ordered them released (Sahih Muslim 2613).

The Prophet ﷺ even said a woman was punished in the Hereafter because she locked up a cat, neither feeding it nor letting it find food, until it died (Sahih al-Bukhari 3482). If cruelty to an animal is that serious, cruelty to a human being is far worse. See Are animal fighting sports haram?

Forced confessions don't count

The Prophet ﷺ said that Allah has excused his community for mistakes, forgetfulness and what they are forced into (40 Hadith an-Nawawi 39). Building on this, the classical schools (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali) treat a confession under threat or beating as invalid in court. So torture is not only cruel; it also fails as a way to establish the truth.

What about Islamic punishments?

People sometimes confuse torture with the fixed hudud penalties in classical law. These are different things: hudud were limited, needed very strict proof, and were meant to be avoided whenever there was doubt. They were never a license to beat suspects or extract information. See What are hudud punishments in Islam?

Sadly, some governments in Muslim-majority countries torture prisoners, just as some governments elsewhere do. That is a violation of Islam, not an example of it.

Key points
  • The Quran honors every human being, including prisoners.
  • The Prophet ﷺ warned that those who torment people will be tormented by Allah.
  • A confession under force is invalid in classical Islamic law.
  • Torture by any government is a betrayal of Islamic teaching.
Tip: If this topic touches your own past, you don't have to carry it alone. A trained counselor can help, alongside your faith. See How do I heal from trauma as a Muslim?

People also ask

Can Muslims bow to the King or Queen?

No, Muslims shouldn't bow or prostrate to a king or queen, as these acts belong to Allah, but a handshake or polite nod is fine.

Read the full answer →
Is shoplifting haram?

Yes, shoplifting is haram: it is theft, even from big supermarkets or self-checkouts. Repent and repay what you took to clear it, in sha Allah.

Read the full answer →
Is it haram to use a fake address for a school place?

Yes, using a fake address for a school place is haram. It is lying and cheating, and it can take a place from a child who is genuinely entitled to it.

Read the full answer →
Can Muslims join a neighborhood watch?

Yes, Muslims can join a neighborhood watch. Keeping neighbors safe is a good deed in Islam, as long as you avoid spying, profiling and gossip.

Read the full answer →
What are dar al-Islam and dar al-harb?

Dar al-Islam and dar al-harb are classical terms for lands under Muslim rule and lands at war; most scholars see the West as a land of peace.

Read the full answer →